I first tried the Puig touring, better than stock but no airflow and Texas is hot 8 months out of the year besides to me it looks horrible (no offense), then tried the Puig sport. less buffeting than stock but still had quite a bit. Then I cut down my stock shield, far less buffeting but noisy. I finally Bit the bullet and got the MRA vario, Should have done that in the first place. It just simply works, nice quiet, and still get good clean airflow with it all the way down.