Home
Search
Member Map
Photos Gallery
Login
Register
VIEW MEMBERS
ERROR LOG
MAINTAIN DATABASE
ATTACH & AVATARS
MANAGE THEMES
BLOCK LIST
Login/Register
RECENT POSTS
UNREAD TOPICS
UNREAD REPLIES
PHOTOS GALLERY
HELP PAGES
ACCOUNT
SETTINGS
FORUM
PROFILE
MY POSTS
MESSAGES
NEW = 0
LOGOUT
Recent Posts
Please
login
or
register
LOGIN
JOIN
BMW S1000XR
»
S1000XR Chat
»
Maintenance, Servicing, and Mechanical
»
Front brake spongy feeling
09 Jun 23, 22:24 pm
1
2
3
Go Down
Author
Front brake spongy feeling (Read 913 times)
0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.
GatlingOr.
XR Junior ‐
11
Topic Author
GatlingOr.
XR Junior
Topic Author
Posts: 11
Country:
Front brake spongy feeling
on:
April 01, 2023, 03:18:24 pm
April 01, 2023, 03:18:24 pm
Hi all,
I've been riding my 2016 XR with 20K kilometers for a couple of months now. There's one thing that bothers me, and it's the front brake. Not the stopping power or the bite, which are very good, but the lever return. It returns in a spongy kind of way, if that makes sense. It's not necessarily slow, but it's slower than it should be imo. It definitely doesn't snap back superquick when you let it go. The return is linear and smooth though.
I've ridden a lot of bikes, and haven't experienced this before. For all I know it could be the XR's brake by default, but I wouldn't know. For what it's worth (if anyone has the same reference), I ride 1250RT's for my work daily and they do have that snappy return which I consider is how it should be.
I have rebuild the front master cylinder, bled the system twice (including the ABS pump with MotoScan), replaced front brake pads with Brembo's and I cleaned + greased up the lever. All that's left would be rebuilding both front brake calipers, but I don't wanna go there if I'm just nitpicking. The MC should be the only part responsible for the return, so I'm not sure to go the (costy) length to rebuild the calipers.
Any thoughts or experiences are appreciated. Thanks!
Last Edit: April 01, 2023, 03:41:07 pm by GatlingOr.
Antares
XR God ‐
1663
#1
Antares
XR God
Posts: 1663
Bike: 2015 XR Sport SE
Town: Staines/Kirklees
Country:
Re: Front brake spongy feeling
Reply #1 on:
April 01, 2023, 04:29:35 pm
April 01, 2023, 04:29:35 pm
Pretty common complaint for the Gen 1 and unfortunately your only solution is to get a new MCS and potentially callipers. I was well on my way to upgrading to RCS19+M4s until my XR got written off. It's just something with the setup of MC, ABS and callipers. Not sure which part as from what I recall most of the Gen 2s have the same callipers and MCs and from the couple I rode they're pretty firm. That said lot of people complaining about this resolved the issue with new MCs, new Callipers or both.
That's if you can call this an "issue". My biggest complaint was that with the higher mileage it started to get less consistent, sometimes 1 inch from the bars it's hard, other times 0.5 inches.
Last Edit: April 01, 2023, 04:30:27 pm by Antares
GatlingOr.
XR Junior ‐
11
Topic Author
#2
GatlingOr.
XR Junior
Topic Author
Posts: 11
Country:
Re: Front brake spongy feeling
Reply #2 on:
April 01, 2023, 05:06:50 pm
April 01, 2023, 05:06:50 pm
Originally Posted by
Antares
Pretty common complaint for the Gen 1 and unfortunately your only solution is to get a new MCS and potentially callipers. I was well on my way to upgrading to RCS19+M4s until my XR got written off. It's just something with the setup of MC, ABS and callipers. Not sure which part as from what I recall most of the Gen 2s have the same callipers and MCs and from the couple I rode they're pretty firm. That said lot of people complaining about this resolved the issue with new MCs, new Callipers or both.
That's if you can call this an "issue". My biggest complaint was that with the higher mileage it started to get less consistent, sometimes 1 inch from the bars it's hard, other times 0.5 inches.
That's very interesting to read, cheers. I didn't know this was a thing.
Braking is consistent, but just not how I like it. I'm considering MC before new calipers (both might be a bit too much, money wise). Guess I'll do some digging on how to get the RCS19 fitted properly.
Antares
XR God ‐
1663
#3
Antares
XR God
Posts: 1663
Bike: 2015 XR Sport SE
Town: Staines/Kirklees
Country:
Re: Front brake spongy feeling
Reply #3 on:
April 01, 2023, 05:13:39 pm
April 01, 2023, 05:13:39 pm
Originally Posted by
GatlingOr.
That's very interesting to read, cheers. I didn't know this was a thing.
Braking is consistent, but just not how I like it. I'm considering MC before new calipers (both might be a bit too much, money wise). Guess I'll do some digging on how to get the RCS19 fitted properly.
Ooh, might not wanna go with an RCS19 with the stock callipers. Necessarily.
RCS17: longer travel, more feel
RCS19: Firmer lever, more wooden
From what i know the stock Nissins are 18mm.
M4 pistons (matched with RCS 19): 34MM
M50 Pistons (Matched with RCS17): 30MM
XR uses M4.32 with 32MM pistons.
Pick and choose your poison.
GatlingOr.
XR Junior ‐
11
Topic Author
#4
GatlingOr.
XR Junior
Topic Author
Posts: 11
Country:
Re: Front brake spongy feeling
Reply #4 on:
April 01, 2023, 05:24:41 pm
April 01, 2023, 05:24:41 pm
Originally Posted by
Antares
Ooh, might not wanna go with an RCS19 with the stock callipers. Necessarily.
RCS17: longer travel, more feel
RCS19: Firmer lever, more wooden
From what i know the stock Nissins are 18mm.
M4 pistons (matched with RCS 19): 34MM
M50 Pistons (Matched with RCS17): 30MM
XR uses M4.32 with 32MM pistons.
Pick and choose your poison.
Thanks, saved me loads of time to look that up.
RyanGTXR
XR Pro ‐
449
#5
RyanGTXR
XR Pro
Posts: 449
Bike: KTM 1290 GT
Town: Notts
Country:
Re: Front brake spongy feeling
Reply #5 on:
April 01, 2023, 06:18:47 pm
April 01, 2023, 06:18:47 pm
If you change the M/C you'll need either a radial banjo convertor (comes off M/C at 90 degrees and then O.E brake line bolts to it, looks sh#t but works) or replace M/C to ABS unit brake line.
I put Brembo MCS 19-21 M/C and M50 calipers on mine. Like night and day compared to stock set up. Much more initial bite, power and feel.
mjojom
XR Pro ‐
101
#6
mjojom
XR Pro
Posts: 101
Bike: s1000xr
Country:
Re: Front brake spongy feeling
Reply #6 on:
April 06, 2023, 12:04:09 pm
April 06, 2023, 12:04:09 pm
Hi Guys, so I will be replacing my front MC too for a radial one, and therefore I need a new line from ABS unit to the front MC. looking at ABS seems all banjos are of a slightly different angle.
I do not want to be taking the tank off just yet, could someone please tell me which line on the ABS unit is to the front MC as I need to get a custom hose. I read here that the new hose length is approximately 1100mm, is that correct?
Thanks a lot
Joe
GatlingOr.
XR Junior ‐
11
Topic Author
#7
GatlingOr.
XR Junior
Topic Author
Posts: 11
Country:
Re: Front brake spongy feeling
Reply #7 on:
April 06, 2023, 12:07:54 pm
April 06, 2023, 12:07:54 pm
Originally Posted by
mjojom
Hi Guys, so I will be replacing my front MC too for a radial one, and therefore I need a new line from ABS unit to the front MC. looking at ABS seems all banjos are of a slightly different angle.
I do not want to be taking the tank off just yet, could someone please tell me which line on the ABS unit is to the front MC as I need to get a custom hose. I read here that the new hose length is approximately 1100mm, is that correct?
Thanks a lot
Joe
I just put on the tank so can't check unfortunately. I did see another topic on this forum where someone marked his ABS-pump with MC and 'front brakes', just so you can tell which line goes where. Shouldn't be too hard to find. The pic is in a topic about changing the front brake assembly. The length is also named.
Good luck and let us know the results after changing!
RyanGTXR
XR Pro ‐
449
#8
RyanGTXR
XR Pro
Posts: 449
Bike: KTM 1290 GT
Town: Notts
Country:
Re: Front brake spongy feeling
Reply #8 on:
April 06, 2023, 12:16:33 pm
April 06, 2023, 12:16:33 pm
M/C line is No. 3 in your picture. 1150 is for ABS to t-piece if changing caliper lines. for M/C line this is what I ordered from Venhill -
Line Builder
SKU: linebuilder-3/60081/BLACK-3/60082/BLACK-3H1425B-BK-C101-1
Fitting A
1 x M10 STRAIGHT BANJO, BLACK £7.60
Fitting B
1 x M10 20° BANJO, BLACK £4.64
Hose
1 x 1425mm BLACK HOSE BLACK SWIVEL NUTS £24.48
Washer 1
4 x 10MM COPPER WASHER £0.29
Hose Swivel Nut
Black
Different line manufacturers take the line length from different points so check with whichever brand you go for.
Last Edit: April 06, 2023, 12:17:50 pm by RyanGTXR
mjojom
XR Pro ‐
101
#9
mjojom
XR Pro
Posts: 101
Bike: s1000xr
Country:
Re: Front brake spongy feeling
Reply #9 on:
April 06, 2023, 12:32:09 pm
April 06, 2023, 12:32:09 pm
Originally Posted by
RyanGTXR
M/C line is No. 3 in your picture. 1150 is for ABS to t-piece if changing caliper lines. for M/C line this is what I ordered from Venhill -
Line Builder
That is excellent info, I am just slightly confused. I am not changing calipers just yet, only MC. There is a straight line that foes from MC to the ABS unit, correct? And it is #3 in my picture. I have bar risers too so I want to be slightly generous with my custom, hose. But, the length of that hose to the MC is what? (the T piece confuses me here, I understand that #3 going directly to the MC not to the T piece)
thank you very much
1
2
3
Go Up
Recent Topics
M1000XR
[
S1000XR - General Chat
]
wessie
Today
at 06:45:18 pm
Another one added
[
Bikers Chat
]
RichieRich
Today
at 06:44:06 pm
Bit of a wobble
[
S1000XR - General Chat
]
Emtee
Today
at 05:12:32 pm
Toprak to BMW for 2024
[
S1000XR - General Chat
]
sipaldi
Today
at 04:31:24 pm
Anyone know where to get this seat!?!?
[
S1000XR - General Chat
]
sipaldi
Today
at 04:27:32 pm
Fork seal replacement
[
Maintenance, Servicing, and Mechanical
]
RichieRich
Today
at 04:09:31 pm
Camshaft Issue ?
[
Maintenance, Servicing, and Mechanical
]
Salish1000
Today
at 05:23:59 am
Gen 2 OEM exhaust end can
[
Items Wanted
]
Disrepair
Yesterday
at 10:55:04 pm
18K Service cost
[
Maintenance, Servicing, and Mechanical
]
RichieRich
Yesterday
at 05:25:21 pm
Dash cam or Helmet cam?
[
S1000XR - General Chat
]
philbuck
Yesterday
at 12:22:47 pm